Thanksgiving 1621 ~ Gratitude and Diplomacy
The Indigenous peoples of the Plymouth Colony, Massachusetts area in 1621 heard gunfire from the English Colonists who were out hunting fowl: duck, pigeons and geese to celebrate their fall harvest. The Wampanoag tribe, interested in diplomatic alliance not necessarily friendship yet, decided to join and brought with them venison and corn. Historians believe the concept of the first Thanksgiving was in 1621 in Massachusetts and with careful research have concluded this Autumn Harvest celebration was more about gratitude for the harvest and diplomacy. Let’s compare and contrast 2026 with 1621 and how the concept of a November Holiday called Thanksgiving was and is currently celebrated. In fact, the eyewitness accounts do not mention turkey but there were wild ones available.
The contrast starts with a written fact, Edward Winslow with his wife, came over on the Mayflower and wrote exactly what took place and two decades later the first Governor of the Plymouth Colony, William Bradford also wrote notes detailing that first concept of Thanksgiving confirming it. It’s clear very few of the foods American enjoy today were available to the English Settlers or the Native Americans in 1621 off the coast of Massachusetts. The early settlers in fact did not eat that exact meal we have all come to enjoy and look forward to especially the huge turkey. It is highly probable they ate mostly venison and fish including, cod, sea bass, oysters, mussels, eels and lobsters which were so abundant they also used lobsters for fertilizer. Their vegetables included multi color hard flint corn, pumpkins, cabbage, leeks, cucumbers, carrots, artichokes, walnuts and grapes. The pumpkin shells were used to warm up custards and honey for a treat but cranberries were more of a garnish with no sugar and very very tart. The indigenous peoples who were guests also contributed all of their venison, and much more.
There were perhaps around 50 English Settlers alive after a bad winter that took many women and children, in fact only 4 women attended the first Thanksgiving Harvest Celebration. The guests included around 100 Indigenous people. That tribe was called WAMPANOAG and its leader King Massasoit. Both the Wampanoag Tribe and the English Settlers used knives and spoons to eat and there were no forks. The entire table was set with linen napkins. The Native Americans offered 5 deer as a major contribution to the meal as venison meat was scarce. There were no white potatoes yet or sweet potatoes that came years later. It’s highly probably water was the main drink available. The first Thanksgiving was a shared meal with both groups cooking and preparing and cleaning it up. Most of the women who came over on the Mayflower died that first winter so the meals were prepared by the young men from the tribe and the English teenagers along with the four wives in the colony. It lasted 3 full days. The leaders met to discuss an alliance against aggressive tribes so it was diplomacy that created the eventual friendship.
It was also successful because one man, a Native American who had been abducted years before by Spanish slave traders by brutal force, and taken to Spain and hard labor. Squanto was then sold to Catholic Friars who eventually got him to an English abolitionist and they arranged for his safe return to the Pawtucket tribe and Wampanoags. This brave young man was named Squanto and after returning he found his village gone from severe illness and the English Colonists there. Squanto who spoke perfect English lived with the colonists for a few years and taught them the best farming methods and translated when the Wampanoags visited. Squanto is credited with teaching the English Colony the Three Sisters Method of growing corn, beans and squash to support each other’s growth. This is an interesting metaphor. With Squanto translating, diplomacy was achieved and trust between the groups existed between those groups for that snapshot in history. The men taught each other military defensive tactics and even marched in formation together. The celebration of friendship lasted three days. By all written accounts the friendship lasted much longer between the groups.
A writer named Alexander Young rediscovered Bradford’s notes of the First Thanksgiving in the 1850’s and then not long after another writer named Sarah Josepha Hale, actually a novelist and magazine owner published her concept of what Thanksgiving should look like including our iconic Thanksgiving turkey in the center of the table with yams and lots of sugar in the cranberry relish. By then, the white potatoes and yams and a variety of green vegetables and of course corn bread stuffing. Sarah who was very influential wrote to several presidents asking them to create a permanent American Holiday, with the first few declining. Abraham Lincoln finally said yes in 1863 and declared the final Thursday in November as Thanksgiving. ..With gratitude to Squanto, Edward Winslow, King Massasoit, William Bradford and Sarah Josepha Hale for her role in present day Thanksgiving.

You must be logged in to post a comment.